The clearest signs your gutters need repairing rather than clearing are a drip from the same spot every time it rains, water still lying in the gutter an hour after the rain stops, and a run you can see has dropped or tilted. Water pouring over the front edge only in a downpour is usually a blockage. Where and when the water escapes tells you which one you have.

It matters because people pay for the wrong job. A gutter that has failed can be emptied every year and still soak the same patch of wall.

What are the signs your gutters need repairing?

Next time it rains properly, go out with a coat on and watch where the water escapes. Each place points at a different fault.

  • Over the front, all along the run. The gutter is full and the water has nowhere else to go. That is a clear.
  • A steady drip at one point. Look up. If it lines up with a join between two lengths, or with the corner piece, the seal in that joint has gone.
  • Down the wall behind the gutter. The gutter has tipped back or pulled away, so water runs off the tiles and misses it. That is brackets, or the board they are screwed into.
  • From the top of the downpipe. The outlet or the pipe itself is blocked or cracked, and the gutter is fine.

In dry weather, look for the evidence instead: a dark streak on the brickwork under one spot, moss growing on the sill below, or a worn patch in the path where water lands. One narrow stain says joint. A long stain the length of the house says overflow.

Why do gutter joints start leaking?

A plastic gutter is lengths clipped into joining pieces, and each joint relies on a rubber seal. Those seals go hard with years of sun and frost, and the plastic grows and shrinks with the weather, so the seal works loose a fraction at a time. A gutter that has been left full makes it worse, because the weight of wet soil sits right on the joints.

The fix is usually small. The joint is taken apart, cleaned and resealed, or a new joining piece goes in. A customer in Pontefract posted their job on MyBuilder in August 2024 as guttering joint has come apart. One joint, not a whole gutter.

Why does water sit in my gutter after the rain stops?

A gutter is meant to slope very slightly towards the downpipe. If a bracket drops, a screw pulls out of the timber, or someone once leant a ladder on the run, the slope flattens or reverses, and water sits in the low spot until it evaporates.

Standing water is a repair sign for two reasons. It adds weight that drags the run down further, and it leaves silt behind that builds into the next blockage. Clearing it only resets the clock. The run needs lifting and re-hanging so it falls the right way again. On a job in Castleford in August 2023 I re-aligned the whole system and fitted brackets with new screws, which is what a dropped run usually needs.

Can a gutter be blocked and broken at the same time?

Often. A blocked gutter hides its faults, because you cannot see a split under a foot of soil, and the weight of that soil is often what caused the split in the first place. That is where the before and after photos earn their keep. You see what was in there, and you see what was underneath it.

It works the other way round too. Sometimes a gutter someone thinks is cracked is only full, and once it is emptied it drains fine. I would rather tell you that than sell you a repair you do not need.

Is it the gutter, or the board behind it?

If the gutter is pulling away from the wall rather than just leaking, check the fascia board it hangs from. A new bracket screwed into soft timber will not hold for long. If the paint is flaking, the wood looks dark or a screwdriver goes into it easily, that board needs sorting before the gutter goes back up. My fascias and soffits page covers how I decide whether it can be patched or needs replacing.

What does a gutter repair cost?

I cannot give you a figure without seeing it, and anyone who does is guessing. A single joint on a bungalow is a small job. A dropped run along the back of a three storey house, above a conservatory, is a very different one. A leak you can see from the path sometimes has a second one hiding further along.

One thing that keeps the cost down is doing both jobs on the same visit. In Pontefract in August 2024, a customer's downpipe repair and gutter clean were both handled on the same day, one trip instead of two. If yours needs clearing and fixing, it makes sense to have both done in one go.

When to ring someone

If the same spot drips every time it rains, water is sitting in the gutter, or a length has visibly dropped, it wants fixing rather than emptying. The details are on the gutter repairs page. If you watched it in the rain and it only overflowed along the front, you probably only need gutter clearing.

I cover Mexborough and twenty miles around it, including Barnsley and Rotherham, with photos of past repairs on my work page.

Take a photo of the drip and the wall under it, and WhatsApp both to 07515 154559. I will tell you whether it looks like a joint, a bracket or a blockage. I do not charge to come and look, and the quote is free.